Why Southwark Council’s Attack on Letting Agents Is Misguided

Southwark Council’s recent declaration that letting agents are “predatory and exploitative” is both misleading and counterproductive. While their concerns about affordability are valid, attributing the housing crisis solely to letting agents ignores the complexities of the rental market and the critical role these professionals play in ensuring its functionality. Let’s unpack the realities of the housing market and propose constructive solutions that address the true causes of the crisis.

The Essential Role of Letting Agents

Letting agents are an integral part of the private rental sector (PRS), acting as intermediaries who support both landlords and tenants. Their responsibilities include:

• Ensuring Compliance: Letting agents ensure landlords meet safety and legal standards, protecting tenants’ rights and wellbeing.
• Managing Tenancies: From tenant vetting and lease agreements to ongoing property maintenance, letting agents handle the administrative and operational aspects of renting.
• Balancing the Market: By setting rental prices based on market trends, they ensure fair competition and help regulate the supply and demand equilibrium.

Dismissing letting agents as “exploitative” undermines their role in keeping the rental market professional, safe, and accessible for millions of tenants.

The Real Issue: Supply and Demand Imbalance

The council’s stance overlooks the fundamental problem of housing supply and demand. Urban areas like Southwark face immense pressure due to limited housing stock, rising populations, and growing tenant demand.

Key points to consider:

• A Shortage of Housing Stock: With fewer properties available than needed, tenants are forced into fierce competition, driving up rents naturally through demand.
• Impact of Overregulation: Excessive regulations and hostile policies toward landlords deter investment in the rental market, exacerbating the housing shortage.

Measures like banning bidding wars may provide short-term relief for a minority of tenants but fail to address the root cause of the affordability crisis: a lack of housing.

The Importance of a Free Market

In a free-market economy, housing prices are determined by supply and demand dynamics. Interventions that disrupt this balance can lead to serious unintended consequences:

1. Decreased Investment: Overregulation and vilification of letting agents and landlords may discourage further investment in rental properties.
2. Worsened Property Quality: When landlords’ margins are squeezed by restrictive measures, maintenance and upgrades to rental homes often suffer.

Rather than demonising market participants, Southwark Council should focus on encouraging collaboration and investment to strengthen the PRS.

The Solution Lies in Collaboration

If Southwark Council truly wants to address affordability, they should adopt strategies that bring all stakeholders—councils, landlords, letting agents, and tenants—together. Constructive solutions could include:

• Increasing Housing Stock: Simplify planning processes and incentivise the development of affordable housing.
• Supporting Landlords: Provide tax breaks or subsidies for landlords who maintain affordable rents or upgrade properties to higher standards.
• Promoting Transparency: Facilitate open communication between letting agents, landlords, and tenants to ensure fair and ethical practices.

Instead of stigmatising letting agents and landlords, a collaborative, market-driven approach can achieve sustainable improvements in housing affordability.

Vilifying letting agents as “predatory” might make for dramatic headlines, but it fails to address the true challenges facing Southwark’s rental market. Letting agents are not the enemy; they are key players in providing housing to thousands of tenants. The focus should be on solving the root causes of the crisis—namely, increasing housing supply and encouraging responsible investment.

The housing market works best when all participants—landlords, agents, tenants, and councils—collaborate toward a common goal: a fair, functional, and sustainable rental sector.

We were so impressed with how LettingSupermarket.com manage our own buy to let property portfolio we decided to acquire a substantial stake in the company.

LettingSupermarket.com charge just 6% of rent for a full management service. Their letting fees are just £300 per tenant which includes block viewings, tenant referencing, inventory, check in/out, dealing with utility company changeovers and a whole lot more.

Share This Article