What Can a Landlord Do if the Cost of Repair Exceeds the Deposit Held?

When a tenant vacates a rental property, it’s not uncommon for the landlord to discover damages or the need for repairs that exceed the amount of the security deposit held. This situation can be particularly challenging, as the deposit is intended to cover such costs. However, landlords do have options to recover additional expenses.

One effective method is through a small claims court application, specifically known as Money Claim Online (MCoL). This article explores the steps a landlord can take and the potential outcomes for both the landlord and tenant, emphasizing the importance of detailed check-in inventory reports and check-out inspections with dated photos.

Importance of Detailed Check-In Inventory and Check-Out Inspection

A thorough check-in inventory report and check-out inspection are critical for documenting the property’s condition at the start and end of a tenancy. These reports, ideally accompanied by dated photos, provide clear evidence of any damages or changes to the property, supporting the landlord’s claim if disputes arise.

Check-In Inventory Report: This should include a detailed list of the property’s contents and condition at the beginning of the tenancy, supported by high-quality, dated photos.

Check-Out Inspection: At the end of the tenancy, conduct a thorough inspection, documenting any changes or damages with detailed notes and dated photos. Compare these findings to the check-in report to clearly identify any tenant-caused damages.

Assessing the Damage and Costs

Before taking any legal action, it’s crucial for landlords to thoroughly document the damages and obtain detailed estimates or invoices for the necessary repairs. This documentation, alongside the check-in and check-out reports, serves as essential evidence in any potential court proceedings.

Communication with the Tenant

The first step should always be to communicate with the tenant. Provide a detailed breakdown of the damages and associated costs, along with the supporting evidence from the check-out inspection and the original check-in inventory. Request the balance owed. Often, tenants may be willing to settle the amount owed to avoid legal proceedings and the potential consequences that come with it.

Using Money Claim Online (MCoL)

If the tenant refuses to pay or disputes the claim, landlords can use the Money Claim Online (MCoL) service to pursue the debt. MCoL is an online service provided by the HM Courts & Tribunals Service in the UK, allowing individuals and businesses to claim money owed to them without the need for a lawyer.

Steps to File a Claim Using MCoL:

1.Register for an Account: Visit the MCoL website and register for an account.

2. Prepare Your Claim: Gather all necessary information, including the tenant’s details, the amount being claimed, and evidence of the damages and repair costs. Ensure that your check-in inventory and check-out inspection reports with dated photos are included as evidence.
3. Submit Your Claim: Complete the online claim form and pay the applicable fee. The fee varies depending on the amount being claimed.
4. Serve the Claim: Once submitted, the claim will be served to the tenant, who then has 14 days to respond.

Possible Outcomes

Tenant Pays: The tenant may decide to pay the amount owed upon receiving the claim.

Tenant Defends the Claim: The tenant may choose to dispute the claim, leading to a court hearing where both parties present their case.

No Response from Tenant: If the tenant does not respond within 14 days, the landlord can request a default judgment.

Consequences for the Tenant: County Court Judgment (CCJ)

If the court rules in favour of the landlord, a County Court Judgment (CCJ) will be issued against the tenant. A CCJ can have significant implications for the tenant, including:

Credit Rating Impact: A CCJ will negatively impact the tenant’s credit rating, making it difficult for them to obtain loans or credit in the future.

Enforcement Actions: If the tenant still fails to pay, the landlord can take further enforcement actions.

Enforcement Options: Attachment of Earnings

One effective enforcement action is applying for an Attachment of Earnings Order (AEO). This order allows the landlord to recover the debt directly from the tenant’s wages. The tenant’s employer will be instructed to deduct a specified amount from the tenant’s salary until the debt is paid in full.

Steps to Apply for an Attachment of Earnings:

Apply for an AEO: If the CCJ remains unpaid, the landlord can apply for an AEO through the court.

Court Review: The court will review the application and, if granted, send an order to the tenant’s employer.

Deductions from Salary: The employer will make regular deductions from the tenant’s wages and send them to the court, which will then forward the payments to the landlord.

If the tenant leaves their job, you can still have the attachment of earnings transferred to their benefit claim though this may be aa lesser amount as most deductions from benefits are limited to a max of 20% off the standard allowance which is currently £393.45 per month

While facing repair costs that exceed the security deposit can be daunting, landlords have a clear legal pathway to recover the additional expenses. By maintaining detailed check-in inventory reports and conducting thorough check-out inspections with dated photos, landlords can strengthen their claims. Utilising the Money Claim Online (MCoL) service and potentially securing an Attachment of Earnings Order ensures landlords are compensated for the damages incurred. It’s important to handle the process methodically, ensuring all communications and claims are well-documented to support a successful outcome.

Share This Article