The Realities of Private Sector Landlords: Profit, Costs, and the Rental Market

In recent years, the private rental market has come under intense scrutiny, with accusations of landlords profiteering at the expense of tenants.

On average, tenants are spending about 38% of their income on rent, raising questions about the fairness and sustainability of the rental market. However, a closer examination reveals that the financial pressures faced by landlords have also intensified, challenging the narrative that landlords are simply exploiting tenants for profit.

The Rising Costs for Landlords

Landlords have experienced significant increases in their operational costs, influenced by several factors:

Mortgage Rates

A period of high inflation resulted in a series of hikes to the Bank of England’s base rate, culminating in average buy-to-let rates peaking at 6.79% in August 2023. Many landlords are facing the end of their fixed-rate mortgage periods, only to be confronted with new, substantially higher interest rates. This shift has dramatically increased their monthly mortgage payments, squeezing their margins.

Currently, on average a new 5 year fixed rate BTL mortgage has an initial rate of 4.99% with reverted rates being as high as 8.99% for some lenders, with some landlords seeing their mortgage payments almost double

Regulatory Compliance

The cost of compliance with safety regulations has risen, recent increased in mandatory safety checks come at a cost for landlords. On average a landlord can be paying over £500 to ensure their property is compliant to be rented put for the first time, with ongoing costs of renewals to be factored in.

Pair this with the cost of licensing, in some areas a selective license is required to let out any type of property and not just an HMO, these costs can average between £600-£1000 depending on location

Insurance and Maintenance

Insurance premiums for rental properties have surged, partly due to the increased risk and cost of claims. Additionally, maintenance costs have escalated, driven by the rising prices of materials and labour. Repairs and upkeep, crucial for maintaining property standards, now demand a larger share of a landlord’s budget.

Taxation

The introduction of Section 24 has phased out the ability of landlords to deduct mortgage interest from their rental income before calculating their tax liability. This change has increased the tax burden on landlords, particularly those with high mortgage interest payments.

Letting agency fees

Although many landlords do self manage, with the every increasing and changing minefield of legislation many landlords also opt to use a letting agency to fully manage their property, for a more hands-off approach. This comes with costs, again area dependant but in average a fully managed ser vice can see the agent taking 12% of the monthly rent each month

The Profile of the Average Landlord

Contrary to popular belief, most landlords are not large-scale property moguls sitting on their yacht throwing crumpled £50 notes overboard. NRLA data shows 80% of landlords own only one or two properties with 59% owning only one and operate on tight margins. These small-scale landlords often struggle to break even, let alone generate substantial profits. They face the dual challenges of rising costs and the expectation to keep rents affordable for tenants.

Rent Increases: A Double-Edged Sword

It is a common misconception that landlords frequently hike rents to maximise their profits. In reality, many landlords do not increase rents for extended periods, understanding the financial strain on tenants. However, this can create a precarious situation for both parties:

Tenants

Long periods without rent increases can lead to tenants facing significant jumps in rent when they eventually move to a new property, aligning with current market rates. This sudden increase can be financially destabilising leading many tenants to believe rents are unaffordable.

Landlords

By keeping rents artificially low, landlords may not cover their increased costs, leading to financial strain and potentially forcing them out of the rental market. This reduction in rental supply can further exacerbate housing shortages and drive up rents.

The Business Perspective

Private landlords are investors who run their rental properties as businesses. Like any business, the goal is to be profitable. Profit is not a sign of greed but a necessary component of a sustainable business model. Without the ability to make a profit, landlords cannot maintain their properties, invest in new ones, or remain in the market.

Landlords have increasingly sold more properties than they’ve bought year on year since 2016, according to data from the estate agent Hamptons.

This need to sell was sparked by changes to mortgage interest tax relief, which significantly cut profits for many buy-to-let investors. Data from Savills shows landlords profits hit their lowest levels since 2007 last year.

Recent dada from Zoopla showed that 40% of properties for sale on its platform were previously rented out in the last 3 years.

Landlords who stay in the market are increasingly using limited companies for their portfolio, with around 50,000 buy-to-let companies set up in 2023.

Landlords using company structures can offset 100% of their mortgage interest against their profits and pay corporation tax rather than income tax. However, mortgage rates for limited companies can be significantly more expensive.

Market Dynamics and Tenant Competition

The rental market is also influenced by broader economic forces. High demand and limited supply lead to competitive bidding for rental properties. Increasingly, overseas tenants, who can offer higher rents and pay several months in advance, drive up prices. This competitive environment means that rental prices reflect what tenants are willing to pay as much as what landlords are asking.

The narrative of landlords as profiteers overlooks the complex financial realities they face. Rising costs, regulatory burdens, and market dynamics all play significant roles in shaping the rental landscape. While it is crucial to address the affordability of rent for tenants, it is equally important to understand and consider the challenges landlords encounter.

A balanced approach, recognising the legitimate business interests of landlords and the financial pressures on tenants, is essential for a fair and functional rental market.

Share This Article