Why Private Landlords Pay More and Get Less: The VAT Inequality Exposed

The UK government has made bold promises to deliver 1.5 million new homes, but while that vision might sound like a solution to the housing crisis, there’s a hidden tax trap that could push existing landlords out of the market. Private landlords are facing crushing VAT burdens, paying 20% VAT on almost everything they spend to maintain their properties—repairs, management fees, professional services—yet they can’t reclaim a penny of it.

Meanwhile, corporate Build To Rent (BTR) operators have the advantage of reclaiming VAT, putting small landlords at a massive financial disadvantage. The result? If this VAT inequality continues, we could see 1.5 million existing rental homes disappear from the market, taking with them a significant chunk of VAT revenue that the government can’t afford to lose.

How VAT Crushes Private Landlords

For the average private landlord, VAT is an unavoidable extra cost that eats into profits. Every time a landlord pays for maintenance, property management, or professional services, they’re hit with 20% VAT. Unlike many other businesses, landlords can’t reclaim that VAT.

Here’s a basic breakdown of how VAT impacts a typical private landlord:

Private Landlord’s VAT Burden:

• Annual spend on services (repairs, management, professional fees): £20,000
• VAT at 20%: £4,000
• Total cost to the landlord: £24,000

That extra £4,000 comes straight out of the landlord’s profits—money that could have been used to improve the property, upgrade energy efficiency, or simply keep rents affordable. For smaller landlords operating on tighter margins, this VAT burden can be devastating.

Corporate Build To Rent Operators Have a Huge VAT Advantage

Now, compare this to corporate Build To Rent operators who operate on a much larger scale and, more importantly, can reclaim VAT. For these operators, VAT is far less of a concern, and they can use their tax status to reinvest in expanding their portfolios while paying less overall for the same services.

Here’s an example of how VAT works for a Build To Rent operator:

Build To Rent Operator’s VAT Advantage:

• Annual spend on services: £200,000
• VAT at 20%: £40,000
• VAT reclaimed: £40,000
• Total cost to the operator: £200,000

Because they can reclaim VAT, the corporate operator saves the full £40,000 in taxes, leaving them in a far better financial position to reinvest, expand, and profit.

Worked Example: What Happens When 1.5 Million Landlords Leave the Market?

The UK government has set its sights on building 1.5 million new homes, but what about the homes we already have? If private landlords are driven out of the market by VAT inequality and excessive taxes, we could see up to 1.5 million rental properties disappear. The effects of this mass exodus would be disastrous—not just for the rental market but for the government’s own coffers.

Let’s take a look at the potential VAT impact:

VAT Revenue if 1.5 Million Rental Properties Leave the Market:

• Average landlord’s annual VAT spend on property management, maintenance, and professional services: £4,000
• Total VAT per landlord, per year: £4,000
• Total VAT from 1.5 million landlords:
  • £4,000 x 1,500,000 = £6,000,000,000 (£6 billion) per year

If 1.5 million rental properties are no longer maintained by private landlords, that’s £6 billion in lost VAT revenue every year.

The Bigger Picture: What Happens to Tenants?

When small landlords are squeezed out by unfair taxes, tenants are the ones who really suffer. Fewer private landlords in the market means less competition, fewer affordable homes, and higher rents. As corporate landlords take over, they often focus on maximising profit rather than providing affordable, flexible housing options.

The government may be dreaming of 1.5 million new homes, but if 1.5 million rental homes are lost due to the VAT burden on private landlords, the rental market will become even more corporate-dominated and unaffordable for tenants. The result? Tenants will face higher rents, fewer options, and less security.

Time for Change: Fair VAT Treatment for Private Landlords

It’s time for the government to wake up to the VAT inequality between private landlords and corporate Build To Rent operators. If the goal is to create a fair and competitive housing market, private landlords must be given the opportunity to reclaim VAT on essential services like maintenance, repairs, and management fees.

By levelling the playing field, the government can ensure that small landlords can continue to provide affordable homes to millions of tenants across the country—without being driven out by an unfair tax burden.

It’s Time to End VAT Inequality

The VAT system is putting private landlords at a massive disadvantage, while corporate Build To Rent operators thrive. If the government is serious about housing affordability and creating a fair market, it must act now to allow private landlords to reclaim VAT. Otherwise, we could see millions of rental properties disappear, rents rise, and tenants suffer the consequences. Let’s make sure landlords get the tax relief they deserve and keep the housing market competitive and affordable.

Support Property118: Fighting for Tax Fairness

At Property118, we’re advocating for fairer tax treatment for private landlords, including the right to reclaim VAT. Without tax reform, we risk losing millions of rental homes, squeezing tenants, and creating a rental market dominated by corporate landlords.

We need your help to continue the fight for tax fairness. If you believe in supporting small landlords and ensuring affordable homes for tenants, please consider making a donation.

Every donation counts. Use the form below to help us fight for a fairer tax system that benefits landlords and tenants alike.

Share This Article